Demian's Gamebook Web Page

Username: Password:
Not logged in. You can or Sign Up as a New User


Grey Star the Wizard


Images:
Grey Star the Wizard (British cover)
(British cover)
Grey Star the Wizard (American cover)
(American cover)
Series:The World of Lone Wolf #1
Platform:Web Browser
Translated Into:Der Hexenkönig (German)
Oberon il giovane mago (Italian)
Silverstjärnas ankomst (Swedish)
Le Sorcier Majdar (French)
Authors:Ian Page
Joe Dever (editing)
Illustrators:Iain McCaig (British cover)
Richard Corben (American cover)
Paul Bonner (interior)
Release Dates:October, 1985 (British edition)
March, 1988 (American edition)
April 2, 2003 (Project Aon release)
ISBNs:
Click to shop...
0099447703 / 9780099447702 (British edition)
0425095908 / 9780425095904 (American edition)
Length:350 sections
Number of Endings:28 (not including failure by loss of points)
Summary:As Grey Star, an orphan raised by the magical Shianti, you must begin your journey to find the lost Moonstone and stop Shasarak the Wytch-King from conquering Magnamund. Your first mission is to track down the Lost Tribe of Lara, a race of magical creatures who may be able to help you in your struggle.
BobaGabe's Thoughts:
Click here for more reviews by BobaGabe
At one time I was really into the original Lone Wolf series. However, by the end of that 12th book I was a little tired of the routine.

However, after reading some reviews, I decided it was finally time to head back to Magnamund. So, I grabbed a copy off of eBay, found my old ten sided dice and settled in for some serious page flipping.

It is true that this series shares a lot of similarities to Lone Wolf, but there are two definite improvements.

First, the use of willpower makes the combat more engaging. It adds a bit of gambling to the battles and you actually have to make some tough choices while you fight. At one point I spent 6 willpower points in a desperate attempt to defeat a nasty foe and it was very satisfying to pull it off.

The second big difference in this series is that there are some well done supporting characters. Lone Wolf was always... well... kind on a loner, but Grey Star meets all kinds of interesting characters. It surprised me how much these supporting characters added to the drama and tension.

That being said, I must also agree with the other reviewers. This gamebook is simply broken when it comes to the power of your enemies. I went in knowing this, so I rerolled all of my character stats 3 times and wound up with:

Combat skill: 19 Willpower: 28 Health: 25

Even with these high stats I couldn't get through this nearly impossible quest. The enemies are way too strong. After 4 deaths I gave my character a potion of rejuvenation. Once during the game it allowed my character to max his Willpower and Endurance. With that I finally survived.

This is a very good gamebook IF you do something to adjust the difficulty.

Rating (1-10):
As a book: 7
As a game: 4
Overall: 6

Demian's Thoughts:
Click here for more reviews by Demian
This was the first adventure I ever had in Magnamund, and it's also one of the first gamebooks I discovered and read. As a result, I have very fond memories of the story and its characters, and I have long looked forward to replaying it. Now that I have, though, I'm a little disappointed. Certainly, it has some excellent elements -- memorable non-player characters (a rarity in gamebooks), a variety of nasty monsters, lots of opportunities to cast spells and a bunch of useful items to collect, not to mention plenty of high-quality and memorable internal illustrations. Unfortunately, it also has a lot of flaws. The writing is a bit more bland than I remember it being, but that's not my primary complaint -- most of the book's real problems have to do with poor game design. When I first enjoyed this book many years ago, I cheated to win. I'm glad I did, because if I hadn't, I don't think my memories would have been so fond. The optimal path through the book isn't that hard to find, but it contains enough difficult (and unavoidable) battles that it takes a lot of luck to get through successfully. This means that you can know exactly how to win but be unable to do so simply because of bad rolls of the die (or points at the Random Number Table, if that's how you play). Certainly, success relies on having high initial statistics; this is annoyingly luck-dependent, and a point-distribution system for character attribute generation would have made this a stronger and more balanced book. As it stands, certain aspects of the rules make a potentially entertaining adventure story into a long, repetitive, frustrating mess. This isn't a big deal if you don't mind cheating, but you shouldn't have to cheat to win the game; where's the fun in that? This situation isn't helped by the numerous typographical errors and vague rules embedded in the story's paragraphs; you'd think that by the fifth printing (which is the version I read) that some of these problems could have been cleaned up, but of course they never were. This book isn't as much of a classic as I had hoped, though if it had been given a bit more playtesting and thought, it really could have been.

Hint - Don't be afraid to expend willpower to increase damage in combat -- this is very useful in getting past the tougher fights with a minimum of damage.

utfanatic's Thoughts:
Click here for more reviews by utfanatic
A superior gamebook, with a few flaws.

First of all, the detail and intricacy of the game world is superb. You really feel as if you are immersed in Southern Magnamund and the authors do a brilliant job of conveying the setting. Flora and fauna are explained to a degree rarely found in gamebooks. There is just a neat feeling I get when I come upon Madin Rendalim. I feel like I know him and that his elixir is real, such is the verisimilitude of this world.

The battle and magic system in these books is also excellent, and I appreciate all the opportunities to make use of my chosen magics. However, the authors passed up numerous opportunities to make a choice for magic available where it would have been immensely useful, in order to push the story into the direction they want. For example, when an NPC companion and you are fighting a Quoko, magic as an option is never made available when it would have been a perfectly opportune time to use it.

Writing is above average, but not excellent. However, the backstory and character development are par excellence. The development of character, NPCs, the world in general, as well as small details therein are superb.

The choices are generally well thought out and involve more than simply picking a path or battle. Ability to backtrack is decent. The first half of this book is especially well done, with a myriad of interesting choices, fantastic encounters, and memorable NPCs.

However, there is some technical sloppiness, with a few passages leading to incorrect pages. Sometimes this is obvious, but at least once, it is not, and this could prove crucial, for it is just prior to the most difficult battle in the book. Typos also occur more frequently the further along you progress.

While this book is challenging, it is by no means impossible. I didn't have a single fight until halfway through the book, yet is it THIS fight that can kill you easily. Make it past this and you have a good shot. The other battles are not bad, especially if you use an extra point or two of WP. Plenty of healing is made available, and you will likely need it. The authors want you completely spent at the end of the book, and I was, completely out of WP, and nearly out of endurance. Most of the choices presented in the first half of the book allow logic and stealth (which is advised early on) to bring you success.

All in all, very good book. The interior illustrations are great, but the American cover leaves something to be desired when it comes to the portrayal of Grey Star himself. I would have preferred a little more choice with spells, especially in, or just prior to, battles. But with the vividness with which the world in portrayed and the memorable characters, as well as the great game system, this book is definitely recommended.

Rating 1-10: 8

Errata:Section 3 mentions "your remaining two meals," but depending on events, you may have more or less than two meals by this point. In section 10, the choice that leads to 102 should instead go to section 90. In section 193, pestle & mortar should be listed as a backpack item. In section 266, the choice that leads to 333 should in fact lead to 330. Section 289 covers the greater than and less than cases, but not the equal to case.
Users Who Own This Item:Alarion, AlHazred, AndreAntunes (US), andyr, Aniline, Ardennes (US), B0N0V0X, Barker1952, bookwormjeff (US), brujeria!, casperthegoth, Crazyscotsman, CSquared, dArtagnan, dave2002a, dblizzard72, desdichado66, Dirk Omnivore, Dronak (American), Ed, edwebb, EegahInc, egokun, Ffghtermedic, firefoxpdm, Garrick Muttley, Gartax, girtablilu, gnomeza, Greeneuva, greyarea13, Grifter (US), Haoie, Ian2405 (1985 First Print Beaver Books), Il Santo, Jubal, juski, katzcollection, kinderstef, knginatl (US), Kojiro, le maudit, Lionday, LordJR, Luke, marginal_space, mattender, mlvoss, Mr ? (British Edition), mvstang, nelsondesign, NEMO, nerelax, Nich, ntar (American edition), outspaced, peterm2, Pirrakas (US), plowboy (British), Pseudo_Intellectual, qazplm (US edition), Radjabov, redeyeball, Ryuran333 (British), Sabreman, Salpynx (UK), Sir Olli (UK & US), sireeyore (British), skeleton, skttrbrain, spragmatic (US), Superfro, ThaRid, Threepwud, Tremendez, truce57, twar (US), TWolf, utfanatic, wonderfly, Yalius, zat
Users Who Want This Item:Aryon, Avenger, bookwormjeff (UK), Braldt, Lambchop, yermither
Users with Extra Copies:B0N0V0X
Dronak: American -- clean sheet, spine cracked, front cover has one corner missing, one corner bent; generally good condition
mvstang
ntar: 2 American
Threepwud
utfanatic: American edition, used, in good condition


Related Documents

Play Aids

World of Lone Wolf #1 - #3 Character Sheet (back)

World of Lone Wolf #1 Character Sheet (front)


Demian's Gamebook Web Page (c)1998-2014 Demian Katz.

Individual reviews are the property of their authors.
Trademarks and graphics remain the property of their respective owners and are used here solely for the educational purpose of documenting the history and scope of interactive storytelling. No infringement is intended. If you have any questions or complaints, please contact demiankatz@gmail.com.